The dilemma of how to manage nuclear waste radioactive. Through most of this book ive tried to present the facts, and just the facts, and let. In the essay nuclear waste, author richard muller expresses his concern about. I shared in the 2014 breakthrough prize for this discovery. Muller actually does a poor, ineffective job of communicating his ideas by using an poor pathos, a pathetic logos, and a piteous ethos. Muller first brings to light the most common fears of storing nuclear waste. I, not being interested in nuclear waste, was not interested in this reading. Nuclear waste richard a muller essay click here essay about the turn of the screw the fact writing an essay gcse english the sun bore down on my head hotter friend an unhappy creative writing essay tips helped can i write an. They say i say identifies the key rhetorical moves in academic writing, showing students how to frame their arguments in the larger context of what others have said and providing templates to help them make those moves. In early 2010, muller and his daughter elizabeth founded the group berkeley earth, an independent 501c3 nonprofit aimed at addressing some of the major concerns of the climate.
In 1984, a committee of the international council of scientific unions on the geology of nuclear waste disposal concluded that centurylong interim. Muller, an awardee of the macarthur fellowship and physics professor at uc berkley, states in his 2008 essay nuclear waste, that americans and the rest of the world are overly concerned with radioactive debris and the possibility of nuclear contamination. Summary this is the book that demystifies academic writing, teaching students to frame their arguments in the larger context of what else has been said about their topic and providing templates to help them make the key. What is remarkable is that others havent thought of this, but we think that is the result of us government policy that doesnt allow private companies or individ. A fascinating new interview with prof richard muller, quote. Jun 25, 2014 nuclear waste richard a muller essay click here essay about the turn of the screw the fact writing an essay gcse english the sun bore down on my head hotter friend an unhappy creative writing essay tips helped can i write an. Muller speaks on scientific research about nuclear waste storage, other peoples theories, and alternative ways of storing this type of waste. Muller are all pieces of literature in the book they say, i say by gerald graff and cathy birkenstein. Hidden intellectualism 244 gerald graff nuclear waste 252 richard a. Your goal for this assignment is to summarize the articles main ideas and important points clearly, concisely, and accurately.
At first glance, mullers nuclear waste they say i say. However, formatting rules can vary widely between applications and fields of interest or study. Karen gaffney, raritan valley community college a brilliant book. The paper is basically persuasive he is attempting to convince people that the threat of nuclear waste is just as if not more dangerous. I have read richard rhodes other books the making of the atomic bomb and dark sun. The technology is so compelling that were able to bring onboard these worldclass experts who say. A fascinating new interview with prof richard muller. While the question may be simple, the answer is quite complex. Richard muller sounds like he believes that skeptics har questioned whether or not temperatures have gone up underthe last 50 or so years, that. This book was good but i would have like to have known more of the new types of reactors they are making that are inherently safe. Nuclear energy can provide large amounts of energy without carbon emissions. This fatherdaughter team says it has a cheaper, safer way to.
The bestselling new composition book published in this century, in use at more than 1,000 schools, they say i say has essentially defined academic writing, identifying its key rhetorical moves, the most important of which is to summarize what others have said they say to set up ones own argument i say. Aug 04, 2012 by judith curry the story surrounding richard muller is providing some interesting insights into the psychodynamics of climate change science. Then buy one for your senators and congressman, and insist they read and understand it. The science behind the headlines about a rational, sciencebased approach to nuclear energy as an important and valuable energy source. In the 1960s, rachel carsons book silent spring warned of the ecological effects of. Mcintyre and mckitrick obtained part of the program that mann used, and they found serious problems. Cathy birkenstein the bestselling new composition book published in this century, in use at more than 1,000 schools, they say i say has essentially defined academic writing, identifying its key rhetorical moves. Muller starts his argument by stating that nuclear waste doesn 39.
The public discussion, he says, should take account of the physical and. Tourism argumentative example essay problemfocused assessment is an ongoing process integrated with nursing care to determine the status of a specific. Driving is statistically much riskier than living near a nuclear power plant, but there are many people who think the risks associated with nuclear power are unacceptable. Muller found in the back of the book in the first paragraph, muller mentions loaded terms such as. He is also a faculty senior scientist at the lawrence berkeley national laboratory. Global warming is real, but the things they attribute to climate change. What are prof richard mullers ideas on storage of nuclear waste. Muller nuclear waste is a radioactive waste that is dangerous, and a fair percentage of people would agree on this topic. You know, i cant tell where the foundation is going to put its money thats beyond me but i think when you say ive now reached agreement with 98%, i actually disagree with most of that 98% on many of the things they say, if not most things. I read richard mullers nuclear waste they say i say, pg.
In a recent video interview with the wall street journal, muller said. Barbara ehrenreichs hidden intellectualism 810 words cram. Nuclear waste remains hazardous for thousands of years d. Even so, muller disagrees with those who argue for 10,000 years of absolute safety. In this essay he uses scientific fact to support his opinions, mixing personal views with science. Pursuit of the american dream by barbara ehrenreich 810.
Richard muller of best fame and his wife daughter, elizabeth muller. The public conversion of ucberkeley professor richard muller into a preacher of unscientific agw dogma as truth bears little or no resemblance to the conversion of the saul into paul on the road to damascus this appears to be pr public relations carefully wrapped in a sheepskin of hd human drama that will not help the reputation of agw. Muller, it is possible to come across a number of different metacommentaries used by the author with the purpose to make sure that the readers can correctly understand the reasons of the elaborated information and make sure that the data presented in the discussion is valid but with the shade of personal meaning. The article, nuclear waste, by richard muller discusses the dangers of nuclear waste and his criticism of how important figures are handling the situation. Muller the futile pursuit of the american dream 260 barbara ehrenreich everything that rises must converge 272 flannery oconnor index of templates 293 credits 311 acknowledgments 3. The issue of nuclear waste is not one that people take lightly and is a very.
The physics contributions i am most proud of are as follows. Summary of nuclear waste nuclear waste is dangerous, isnt it. The bestselling new composition book published in this century, in use at more than 1,000 schools, they say i say has essentially defined academic writing, identifying its key rhetorical moves, the most important of which is to summarize what others have said to set up ones own argument. Richard muller and the conversion of a climate change. We have waste and we have to do something about with it muller 210. The irresistable story of richard muller climate etc. Nuclear waste is the leftover nucleus of elements that were split and the result of nuclear fuel.
The issue of nuclear waste is not one that people take lightly and is a very popular topic that needs to be solved. In society, many debates are held over trying to prove to the world that this substance is harmful. Muller born january 6, 1944 is an american physicist and professor of physics at. The skeptic who claims to have debunked climate skepticism never was a skeptic. So it will take about 10,000 years for the waste to decay back to the level of the originally mined uranium. What people need to recognize is that the number of deaths from radioactivity so far in fukushima has been zero and over the next 50 years will probably be fewer than 100 people, whereas the tsunami killed 15,000 immediately. Richard muller and the conversion of a climate change sceptic.
Muller is professor of physics at the university of california, berkeley. Muller did an excellent job of saying why nuclear waste matters to conscious american citizens. However, is it really dangerous or is it just harmful to an extent. The book also provides templates to help students make these key moves in their own writing. He advocates that nuclear waste causes many problems and costs billions of dollars to store. Although he seems to do an adequate job of informing about nuclear waste removable solutions, in his essay, nuclear waste, richard a. In the essay nuclear waste, author richard muller expresses his concern about how to dispose of nuclear waste.
Many students say that it is the first book they ve found that. Muller last week, and although he was whisked backstage by some big secret service staffers after clintons speech, he agreed to answer a few fresh dialogues questions by email. Elizabeth muller and her father, richard muller, at their home in. Richard muller became the darling of the climate denial community a few years ago when he made a number of statements questioning the integrity of.
My daughter elizabeth and i have found the obvious way to dispose off nuclear waste. Is access to nuclear energy worth the risk of creating nuclear waste. Jan 07, 2015 richard muller became the darling of the climate denial community a few years ago when he made a number of statements questioning the integrity of climate scientists and science. Aug 03, 2016 the physics contributions i am most proud of are as follows. Oct 19, 2010 we have waste and we have to do something about with it muller 210. And there were additionally two areas which my son drew to my attention, which had arisen from professor mullers research, which were a new look at the place of nuclear energy and the role of prediction. His etiquette throughout this journal was very studious.
Anthony white eng 2 83018 professor wu 22 february 2014 rhetorical analysis nuclear waste in nuclear waste richard muller takes on the issue of storing nuclear biproducts inside the yucca mountain in nevada. There is no way we can claim that we will be able to store nuclear waste for. Muller born january 6, 1944 is an american physicist and professor of physics at the university of california, berkeley. The futile pursuit of the american dream by barbara ehrenreich, hidden intellectualism by gerald graff, and nuclear waste by richard a. Richard muller, a physics professor at cal berkeley and researcher at laurence berkeley labs, has written a highly accessible book that treats some of the most important, yet misunderstood, topics of our time. Muller estimates 2 in 3 odds that humans are causing global warming. The other issue that people bring up is nuclear waste storage, and they say nuclear. Apr 05, 2018 the original nuclear waste policy act of 1982 authorized the doe to consider nevada, washington, and texas as possible repository sites but the doe failed to carry out the necessary site assessments so in 1987 congress designated nevada as the only permanent u. In a recent video interview with the wall street journal, muller said that despite the fact that the accident at fukushima was far less. The new york times bestselling book on academic writingin use at more than 1,500 schools. The whole purpose of this writing was to deliver information based off of his studies and his confessions on nuclear waste. Richard muller cozying up to bill clinton but theres good news too bill clinton praises his new climate change hero excerpt. Any associated injuries and deaths happen all at once, to the general public c.
Rhetorical analysis nuclear waste anthony white eng. Richard muller is a professor of physics at the university of california at berkely. Jun 15, 2012 richard muller sounds like he believes that skeptics har questioned whether or not temperatures have gone up underthe last 50 or so years, that this has been the or one major issue, and now. Founding and leading, for the first decade of the project that led to the discovery of dark energy. Then we say, you could bury it at the site almost a mile deep, and itll be a permanent disposal, you plug the hole, but it in formations that have not changed in 100 million years.
About berkeleys richard muller, whose recent study on surface temperatures, has caused headlines like climatechange skeptic. And they say, yes, that sounds much more attractive than anything else. His popular science book physics for future presidents and academic textbook physics and technology for future presidents are based on his renowned course for nonscience students. Muller, a professor of physics at the university of california at berkeley, gives his thoughts on the matter of nuclear waste in his essay entitled nuclear waste. View essay summary of nuclear waste from engl 101 at university of maryland, college park. Waste has been depicted as the achilles heel of the nuclear power industry but then too has as been, safety, water, cost and lack of evacuation planning essentially the industry has a lot of problems but the focus of this piece is the spent fuel. Richard muller, physicist from the university of california, berkeley recently released energy for future presidents. Muller the article, nuclear waste, by richard muller discusses the dangers of nuclear waste and his criticism of how important figures are handling the situation. Muller starts his argument by stating that nuclear waste doesnt decay for thousands of years and that trying to store it for 10,000 years in the future is impossible. Willie soon the deep isolation concept is a proposal by dr. I was wrong on climate change covers the significant part of the conversion process.262 593 246 426 81 1162 1030 928 1550 1535 828 827 236 1292 631 338 1473 399 519 82 67 527 467 1484 338 1027 1255 500 1333 1372 655 1182 227 807 614 292 1405 313 1144 1075 1356 603 457 1180 557